The Egyptian Competition Authority takes action against bid rigging Ongoing tightening of antitrust enforcement in Egypt as ECA moves to issue sanctions.
The Egyptian Competition Authority (ECA) has grown increasingly concerned with bid rigging in public tenders. To confront collusions between competitors in public tenders the ECA has increasingly scrutinized public tenders. A particular focus was the energy sector. These investigations, led to the ECA discovering a number of violations in two sub-sectors, the markets for transmission towers and for glaverniced iron pipes. Violations discovered in both markets related to public tenders of Egyptian electricity suppliers.
The ECA found that 10 companies in the transmission towers market had violated the Egyptian Competition Law by unlawfully exchanging information and colluding in public tenders. Furthermore, the authority determined that 5 companies active in the galverniced iron pipes had unlawfully colluded in several public tenders. According to the findings of the ECA these practices negatively impacted quality and pricing of offers received by the electricity suppliers through their tenders distorting the goal of electricity. As a result , these energy suppliers experienced financial burdens that resulted in them charging higher rates to public utilities. Consequently, the ECA found that the violations unduly increased energy prices.
The ECA’s investigations into bid rigging in the energy sector fit into the authority’s overall strategy to confront harmful practices in public procurement. The recently discovered violations led the ECA to establish a specialized department to review tenders and investigate anticompetitive behaviors in relation to tenders. Furthermore, the new department is developing campaigns to raise awareness of the Egyptian competition regime as it pertains to public procurement. These campaigns are envisaged to include public outreach and information as well as training of public sector employees on antitrust matters. In parallel the ECA in cooperation with the General Authority for Governmental Services issued guidelines for public sector employees on how to address anticompetitive practices.
To date the sanctions that will be imposed on the violating companies discovered in the ECA’s recent investigation into the energy sector have not been announced. Based on the ECA’s recent enforcement practice, we do expect the principle sanctions to be fines and that these fines will likely be significant. Pursuant to the Egyptian Competition Law cartels violations may be fined with between 2 to 12 percent of the revenue incurred with the products or services relevant to the violation or fines ranging between EGP 500,000 and EGP 500 million (approx. USD 17,000 to USD 17 million). In recent cartels cases—such as the eggs cartels case we reported on in our client brief of 8 August 2022—the Egyptian authorities have been comparatively aggressive and issued fines towards the higher end. Considering the position taken by ECA officers in discussions and press statements, it appears that this trend will continue.
Bremer maintains offices throughout the Near and Middle East and Africa, positioning clients for success in the region.
21 Soliman Abaza
GIC Tower 3rd Floor
El-Dokki, 12311 Giza
Ras Al Khaimah
United Arab Emirates
4461 Al Hamdi
Mohammad Thunayan Al-Ghanim Street
Kuwait City, Kuwait
Nymphenburger Str. 190
Nymphenburger Str. 190